Friday, September 16, 2016

Survival with Tights

We are all aware of the discrimination X-Men deal with time and time again for their mutation. So are we going to get something different this time? Nope! And I don't care, I am 100% biased when it comes to X-Men. I will most likely love everything that has to do with X-Men (even that one movie that we never talk about). Just a quick disclaimer before you go on with this post.

The X-Men want to be accepted and they want to be part of society as equals. BUT what they want above anything else is to survive. Survival is at the core of everything. We discussed this last class when we were talking about art. I argue that everything stems from survival. We eat to survive, we reproduce to keep the human race alive, we create technology to make it easier to survive, and so on. Survival is a theme in X-Men. In Astonishing X-Men, whether they admit it or not, the X-Men are doing whatever it takes to survive (at least within issues 1-3, we'll see). Yes they are treated unfairly, yes they are oppressed, but forget about all the social injustices. Those injustices do not matter if they are all dead. So Cyclops decided to bring some of them together and not just "make nice with the public," (23) but "astonish them" (24). Public opinion is crucial to the survival of the X-Men (duh).

Emma Frost gave that depressing speech/warning about how humans will always hate them, they can never trust them, and how they will never be at peace (10-12). It seems like there is no hope for the mutants, so why even try to get the public to like them? Because they see that the Avengers, S.H.I.E.L.D., Fantastic Four and all of the other superheroes are not just tolerated, but loved at times. Cyclops thinks that by mimicking them and creating a team of superheroes, the people will automatically change their perception. He thinks superheroes' tights or spandex will help them survive.
https://media0.giphy.com/media/114AZ0sxe9dyMM/200_s.gif
There is one thing that he is forgetting: mutants are people who developed these powers without any explanation. The Avengers, the Fantastic Four and even S.H.I.E.L.D. obtained their powers either because they are aliens, there was some scientific experiment/accident, or just through training. In other words, they have an explanation for being different. It does not matter that the X-Men created a superhero team, the costumes they wear, the people they save. or how many worlds they save. Nothing matters because the humans will always see the mutants as a threat to their survival. They see them as the "next step in evolution... the end of humankind" (25). Just think about how many times you were intimidated by someone who you thought was stronger, smarter, or more attractive than you. Whenever that happens to me, I feel threatened by their perceived superiority. My instincts tell me to either stay away from them or one-up them somehow. The humans are also doing whatever it takes to survive. The humans however, have the support of the government and other non-mutant superheroes. The mutants have no one. Even Nick Fury and S.H.I.E.L.D. will not help them because they are seen as threats, not allies. The mutants are on their own.
https://lovelace-media.imgix.net/uploads/1143/9983e210-0403-0134-24a3-0e1b1c96d76b.gif?

4 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Karen-I hadn't really thought about the role of survival before, until reading your post. With this in mind, it makes sense that the humans are threatened by the mutants, but why are the mutants so hateful towards the humans? Okay, I guess it could be because the humans are trying to kill or change them all, but wouldn't it make more sense to try and show the humans that they could get along and co-exist?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wow Karen! I really never thought about survival being a big part of x-men. It makes a lot of sense. Although some of us are really pushing for mutants and humans to live together as one and treat each other as equals, maybe it really can't be done and we're just being too optimistic. In class we have talked about how x-men could be a metaphor for the civil rights movement. But in comparison, black people and white people are only different due to their skin color while mutants and humans have whole different DNA's. The color of our skin doesn't make us any different but having powers kinda does? I'm kind of rambling now.... but when it comes to survival both groups are definitely afraid of the other group's threat which is really non-exsistant. Maybe its the innate instinct of survival that makes that threat real in both groups eyes?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Building on what Anne said and what was discussed in class about Beowulf, the fear and hate from the mutant side likely stems from the "box" they are forced into by society. Their powers make them unpredictable and dangerous. They are ostracized and threatened with fates like death or depowerment. It would only be a matter of time before this pressure breeds resentment in mutants towards humans, like a self-fulfilling prophecy. The humans believe mutants to be violent and dangerous, so they browbeat and intimidate them until they act violent and dangerous. Pyro from X2 shows this transition when the police show up to arrest him and the others, and he responds by burning their cars and attacking them. It can be assumed that Magneto experienced similar discrimination until it created anti-human sentiments in him as well.

    ReplyDelete